home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT0889>
- <title>
- Jul. 11, 1994: Environment:Winged Victory
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Jul. 11, 1994 From Russia, With Venom
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- ENVIRONMENT, Page 53
- Winged Victory
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> The bald eagle is flying high again, but is the law that helped
- save the majestic bird endangered itself?
- </p>
- <p>By Michael D. Lemonick--Reported by Lawrence Mondi/New York and Mia Schmiedeskamp/Washington
- </p>
- <p> As the national symbol, the bald eagle is supposed to be the
- embodiment of American strength, grace and pride. But for much
- of this century, the majestic bird has been an emblem of the
- country's careless and sometimes callous treatment of wildlife.
- Pinched by human population growth, poisoned by pollutants and
- slaughtered by hunters, the eagle went into such a decline that
- by 1940 Congress felt compelled to pass a law protecting the
- highflyer. It didn't work: in 1963 there were only 417 breeding
- pairs of bald eagles left in the lower 48 states, and by 1978,
- when the eagle was officially listed as endangered, there were
- only a few more than that. It seemed that Americans would soon
- have to travel to Alaska, where the bird has always thrived,
- for a glimpse of their national symbol in the wild.
- </p>
- <p> Now the bald eagle has come back in a big way. The number of
- breeding pairs hit 2,000 in 1988, and after it surpassed 4,000
- last year, biologists said the bird could be dropped from the
- endangered-species list. Last week, in a ceremony timed to resonate
- with the 4th of July holiday, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
- director Mollie Beattie formally proposed that the eagle's status
- be changed from "endangered" to "threatened" everywhere except
- in one region of the desert Southwest. At a marshy spot in Maryland's
- Blackwater National Wildlife Refuge, Beattie marked the long-anticipated
- occasion by releasing a female bald eagle, fittingly named Hope,
- who had been nursed in captivity after suffering a broken wing.
- Following a 90-day public-comment period, the eagle can officially
- come off the endangered list.
- </p>
- <p> Most environmentalists hailed the decision, though a few conservationists
- are concerned that the eagle's changed status could eventually
- put it in danger once again. In fact, the practical impact will
- be minimal; it will still be illegal to hunt or disturb eagles
- or their eggs. At most, it may be slightly easier to encroach
- upon the places where they live. Activities that threaten their
- habitats--logging, for example, or other development--will
- still be subject to review, though the process will probably
- be less stringent and enforcement less aggressive. Says Carl
- Pope, executive director of the Sierra Club: "The signal is
- that there can be more flexibility now, not that it's open season."
- </p>
- <p> Conservation groups trumpeted the eagle's comeback as a triumph
- for the Endangered Species Act of 1973, but the motives behind
- their enthusiastic press releases were partly political. Observes
- Jim Pissot, Washington State director of the National Audubon
- Society: "The Act itself is now endangered." Indeed, the law
- is currently up for reauthorization in Congress, and property
- owners and developers are working hard to have it weakened.
- The law is unfair to their business interests, they say. Besides,
- they insist, the eagle's comeback has much more to do with the
- 1972 banning of DDT, which weakened the shells of birds' eggs,
- and with increased public awareness of the eagle's plight than
- with the law itself.
- </p>
- <p> Sympathetic legislators have introduced amendments that would
- give property owners more leeway in encroaching on animals'
- habitats. The House has trimmed an Administration request for
- increased funding that would have made it easier for the Interior
- Department to enforce the act. At the same time, some of its
- provisions have been successfully challenged in court.
- </p>
- <p> Conservationists agree that the DDT ban played a large role
- in the eagle's revival and that the Endangered Species Act needs
- modification. Along with the Clinton Administration, though,
- they favor strengthening and refocusing the law. Instead of
- concentrating on individual animals such as the bald eagle,
- California condor or gray wolf--an expensive, inefficient
- process and one that necessarily ignores some animals while
- targeting others--environmentalists want to protect entire
- habitats and intervene long before animals are in serious danger.
- </p>
- <p> A model for this new approach is a plan under development for
- California. To protect a bird called the coastal California
- gnatcatcher, officials will try to preserve the sage-scrub ecosystem
- where it lives. That will not only help the gnatcatcher but
- also ease pressures on many other declining species that inhabit
- the scrub.
- </p>
- <p> While the bald eagle prospered under the existing Endangered
- Species Act, it should do just as well under a refocused version.
- Says Karen Steenhof, a wildlife research biologist with the
- Interior Department: "The eagle is still threatened, and there
- is still work to be done. Now it's time to finish the job we
- started: securing the eagle's habitat." If conservationists
- can do that, it will help preserve not just America's proudest
- symbol but plenty of lesser-known but no less important animals
- as well.
- </p>
- <p>OTHER COMEBACKS
- </p>
- <p> Species removed from endangered list or reclassified as
- threatened.
- <table>
- <tblhdr><cell><cell>Date of Change
- <row><cell type=a>Gray whale (California population<cell type=i>1994
- <row><cell>Aleutian Canada goose<cell>1990
- <row><cell>American alligator<cell>1987
- <row><cell>Brown pelican<cell>1985
- <row><cell>Utah prarie dog<cell>1984
- <row><cell>Greenback cutthroat trout<cell>1978
- </table>
- </p>
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-
-